Thursday, December 17th
6:00 - 7:30pm Eastern
Erin Presbyterian Church Classroom
200 Lockett Rd, Knoxville, TN 37919
https://zoom.braverangels.org/4923
Many of our members have quit social media, but if you haven't, please share this page to increase visibility!
This month we're discussing Jonathan Haidt's The Righteous Mind: Why Good People Are Divided by Politics and Religion. Haidt is a social psychologist at NYU, and his book asks the question at the heart of Braver Angels' work: why do decent, thoughtful people look at the same country and reach such different moral conclusions? He builds his answer on three principles.
Intuitions come first, strategic reasoning second. Haidt compares the mind to a rider on an elephant. The elephant, our gut intuition, does most of the steering. The rider, our conscious reasoning, mostly acts as the elephant's press secretary, finding arguments for where it already wants to go. That's why facts and arguments alone so rarely change anyone's mind.
There's more to morality than harm and fairness. Haidt's research identifies six moral foundations: care, fairness, liberty, loyalty, authority, and sanctity. Liberals tend to build their moral views mostly on care, fairness, and liberty, while conservatives draw on all six. Each side tends to see the other's moral concerns as smaller or stranger than they really are.
Morality binds and blinds. Shared values bind us into teams that can accomplish great things together, but the same team spirit blinds us to the good intentions of the people on the other team.
Braver Angels puts many of these ideas into practice. Our workshops and debates aren't about winning arguments. They start with trust and listening, so that people can hear each other well enough to understand the values behind the other side's positions. Haidt's advice is similar: if you want to change a mind, talk to the elephant first. And if each side really is tuned to different moral foundations, then each can see real concerns the other misses, which means we need each other to see the whole picture.
You don't need to have read the book to join us. The videos below start with a six-minute summary of the book, followed by Haidt's TED talk on the moral roots of liberals and conservatives, and a TED interview in which Haidt talks about how a divided America can heal.
Summaries and resources
All of the videos on the book from Haidt's site, righteousmind.com
Before we meet, take the Moral Foundations Quiz and bring your results to compare. Pick whichever version you prefer:
Online: take the quiz at YourMorals.org. You will need to register and fill out a short demographic survey first, and then the site scores your results for you.
Printable: download the Moral Foundations Quiz (PDF). No sign-up is needed, but you tally your own scores using the grid on page 2.
When has an argument, rather than a feeling or a relationship, changed your mind?
Do you agree that our intuitions lead and our reasoning follows?
Which of the six moral foundations matters most to you?
Which foundation do you find hardest to take seriously?
Where do you see "groupishness" in your own life?
How would you "talk to the elephant" of someone you disagree with?